
All the excitement about the return of spring shows has, understandably, centered on “Mad Men” and “Game of Thrones.” Those are good shows. “The Killing” is not. Let’s recap: Last year, “The Killing” debuted with huge ratings and massive support from critics. The pilot was brilliant, establishing a season-long murder investigation in which two detectives would battle the Seattle rain and winnow down a series of suspects until they found their killer. The first few episodes were fairly remarkable. The show was glacially paced, but it felt as though there was a point. Many of us mistook slow pacing for intelligence.
By the end of the season, however, those still clinging to “The Killing” were bored. The show presented too many red herrings and took us on too many pointless detours. But we soldiered on. Why? Because we knew that, at the end of the season, the show would finally reveal the killer of Rosie Larsen and we could all move on with our lives. Few had any interest in a second season.
Then, “The Killing’s” showrunner, Veena Sud, did something absolutely evil. She didn’t allow the detectives to solve the case. She left us with an ambiguous ending and came out immediately to say that it wasn’t really ambiguous at all. The case had not been solved. We’d have to wait another year to find out who killed Larsen. However, Sud revealed that “The Killing” would solve that murder in the first few episodes, then introduce a new investigation.
Fine. We’ll suffer through two or three episodes to find out who killed Larsen, and then we’ll be done with it. Right? Not so fast: Sud then went back on her word, and has now revealed that the murder investigation will fill the ENTIRE season. Twelve more glacially paced episodes until we find out the killer, if Sud doesn’t screw us over again and extend it into a third season.
What’s most criminal here is that Sud had a perfectly good template with which to work. The series is based on a Dutch series of the same name, which was very popular in the Netherlands and even more popular in the UK. But instead of following their single-season murder investigation, an arrogant Sud decided to drag it out and see how long she could test our patience.
Here’s the television spot for the second season of “The Killing,” which you may have seen during commercial breaks on “The Walking Dead.” As you can see, like “Mad Men,” there is no new footage.
For comparison’s sake, here’s the series two trailer for the Dutch series. Even in a language I cannot understand, it looks far more intense, far more compelling, and far more entertaining than Sud’s version.
That’s the show we deserve, damnit. The question is, will you stick around anyway to see who killed Rosie Larsen?



no
They’re stretching the same investigation over another season? No way will I bother watching that. I’ll just tune it to a show with better pacing and smarter characters: Swamp Loggers.
somewhere between choice 2 and 3. i only watch the two hour premier, and then a couple minutes of the next episode. i knew the show sucked after that.
so, i definitely won’t watch and won’t even check out spoilers…unless it happens to get posted here.
Yes.
Goddamn it.
I don’t think I’ll watch. It all comes down to how much time is left over after all the other shows. That pilot really was an amazing episode of television; one of the best I’ve ever seen, but I really feel like I was deceived by the marketing for the show. And I don’t mean I was surprised by a plot twist, which is a good thing. I can’t condone what they did, so I won’t go out of my way to watch.
Nope. They fooled me once. And her attitude afterwards was a big eff you to the viewers.
Exactly this for me as well.
I liked the actors – particulary the two main cops & Rosie’s father (Ensign Ro annoyed me) – and I mostly didn’t mind the pacing, but that ending was just so, so aggravating. Yes, I want to know who the killer is. And, yes, I will wait and read it somewhere on the interwebs.
It’s like 2 Broke Girls…..
…they’ll NEVER earn that 5 k……
..or show tits…
The last episode sucked, but overall, I can only get into police dramas that have season-long investigations. So I like it.
BWAAHAHAHH NO.
I’ll be watching it for sure. The way it ended leaves a bit of mystery that I want to know the truth behind (is Holder actually bad or is he misinformed/being blackmailed). I’ve accepted that they’ll milk the “who killed Rosie” stuff for a while and it’s a mistake. I loved the first season for a most part and feel like the show should have been a case per season (solve Rosie in the end of the first, pick up S2 with Linden and Holder on a new case).
The two lead characters hooked me but I’m kinda tired of being jerked around (every week a new potential killer?). May not watch the whole season but I’m starting it for sure.
+1
Nope
It’ll be like watching the Chyna sex tape.
I’ll watch…but I won’t be happy at any point.
I watch too many shows already. “The Killing” hooked me early but wore me down with tedium as the season went on. I think I booed out loud when the season finale didn’t wrap up anything. I’m done.
Damn, “Nope” has already been taken.
The original series is Danish, not Dutch.
And I really want to say that I won’t be watching, but I probably will, at least for a few episodes.
I’ll watch, but only for that magnificent sweater.
Ironically this show is set to premiere on April Fool’s Day.
Fuck you, “The Killing”, I’m out.
I might watch it long enough to see if the killer has killed more people. If they do that, it might not be entirely unreasonable to stretch it over another season provided they don’t pull 1,000 fake-outs again. Otherwise, they can cover it with Malaria and leeches, sprinkle some Dengue Fever on it and eat a big goddamn jungly dick.
In the immortal words of T-Dog, “Oh Hell no!”
Also no.
Noooooooope
Somehow I watched all of the first season. I’ll start the second, though I doubt I’ll be sticking around long.
Negative. I might read reviews occasionally, but… it’s a Sunday night show, right? No chance I’m watching that shit instead of the actually-good Sunday night stuff.
Who watches TV when it’s actually on? Your argument is invalid.
Heh, fair enough. Point is: a) I would have to care about the show before I thought about DVRing it or watching it online, b) I don’t have a DVR, and c) even if I did have a DVR, I’m pretty sure The Killing would just sit on it, unwatched, and eventually auto-deleted.
I’m not sure I believe anything said or written about the show. We won’t know until it airs. I find it hard to believe after AMC canned the show runner for The Walking Dead for no reason, that they’ll let Sud get away with any more shenanigans. I’d be surprised if they dragged it out much longer, or as someone else on this thread mentioned, perhaps we find out it’s a serial killer. I just can’t wait until the show starts and we get to read all the bitchy comments from people who admit that they never even watched the show.
BTW, I’m still hard pressed to find anything online that definitively states that we were to find out who the killer was by the end of the first season. The only thing any article goes by is the tagline ‘Who killed Rosie Larsen?’ which really doesn’t say anything about a timeline. People read too much into it and are getting upset about nothing. Lost kept crap like this going for multiple seasons and nobody seemed to care this much.
Good point. No one ever complained about Lost.
If EVERYONE is fooled by the marketing, maybe you start to blame the people who created the message?
I wasn’t a fan of Lost, but from what I gather they had viewers interested in the island more so than the thought of them getting off the island. The problem with the Killing (which I watched the entire season of) is that it’s still about who killed Rosie Larsen, and I just don’t think many people care at this point. Myself included.
I actually just re-watched it over the past couple days, and I’ve gotta say, it was good. Something about the pacing, when not dragged out over a 15-week period, played well. Knowing the second season is in a couple weeks rather than 10 months off made the ending seem like a regular cliffhanger. I may be the only one, but I’m looking forward to it. It’s not Breaking Bad, but it’s still pretty damn good.