
We haven’t spent much time discussing the controversy over Daniel Tosh’s rape joke here because literally everyone else on the Internet seems to have that pretty much covered (“It’s stupid!” “It’s serious!” “It was just a joke!” “It was more than just a joke!” “How does this relate to the state of comedy in America? Here are 5,000 words about it!”). Which, you know, fine. The whole point of Freedom of Speech is that somebody gets to say something, then other people get to respond, then other people get to respond to the people who responded, and eventually all that dialogue and sharing of ideas will end up making our society more informed and therefore stronger. I am 100% on board with all of that. But one particular part of this controversy has been driving me straight up a damn tree, and it needs to be addressed: Stop calling it “Tosh-Gate.” In fact, stop adding “-gate” to the end of words altogether.
A brief refresher: The Watergate scandal took place in the 1970s. It involved political operatives breaking into the Waterate complex in Washington D.C. to place wiretaps in the Democratic National Committee headquarters, and the subsequent attempts by the administration of President Nixon to cover it all up. It was one of the biggest scandals in the history of our country, resulting in a massive government sh-tstorm that ended with Nixon’s resignation. Since then, for whatever the hell dumb reason, it has become popular shorthand to tack “-gate” onto the end of a word to indicate some sort of scandal. This is stupid for a number of reasons:
- Watergate was not a scandal about water. It was the name of the place where the scandal originated. The events that have taken place since then imply that we would now call it “Watergate-gate.” That is incredibly stupid.
- The Watergate scandal was a BIG HONKING DEAL. I mean, the president had to quit because of it. That just doesn’t happen. Think of all the other scandals presidents have been involved in before or since: JFK may have stolen the election, Reagan’s administration was involved in shady arms deals, Clinton got a blowjob in the Oval Office and lied about it, etc. None of them had to resign. Comparing it to a comedian saying something mean to a woman in the audience — however you feel about it — is just silly. Unless of course the comedian in question was also the sitting president, and he was forced to step down because of it. Then, by all means, fire away.
- It happened 40 years ago. Forty. And yet we’re still trotting out this lazy “So-and-so was caught with a prostitute. What is your take on Hooker-gate?” garbage. Be original! Be creative! Or at least take the 20 seconds to write out “the controversy involving hookers.” You have the time. I swear to God, you do.
Thank you for your time.



“This reporter suggested ‘Waitergate’ but was shouted down at the press club.”
Basically the Simpsons covered this in one line twenty years ago.
Damnit, that’ll teach me to take the time to look it up and make sure I get the quote right.
People like to be reminded of the past they remember incorrectly.
I wholeheartedly agree that lazy shorthand cheapens the discourse, so I have made it my mission to raise awareness by getting #Gategate trending on Twitter.
That’s why I was pretty thrilled when the called the Freddy Quimby scandal “Beat-Up Waiter” instead of “Waitergate.”
/could really go for a steaming bowl of rich, creamy justice right about now.
This whole thing is just exhausting. Some other celebrity needs to do something controversial, so we can move on.
Mel Gibson, you’ve been kind of quiet lately.
Wouldn’t it be funny if a bunch of commenters just raped Danger right now?
Depends. Can we call it Dangergate?
Personally I think all scandals should now end in “Dome” or “Mobilier”.
/Whole-heartedly agree with your position.
+1 Nice work sir. Nice work indeed.
And we need fewer words that end with —useum.
Still waiting for a scandal at Colgate University so we can be beaten over the head with Colgategate.
Are you kidding? That will never happen. The public relations department at Colgate University has been instrumental in suppressing numerous scandals in the coal mining industry for over a hundred years, just to keep the school’s name out of the mud. They’ve got it down to a science.
This is so going to turn into Warming Glow Comment-Gate 2012.
Somehow, Bill Gates is making money off of this Toshtroversy.
Damn I was going to just do a BillGatesGate comment.
Rape-Gate?
More like Gate-rape, amiriteboys?!?!
Well, that just makes it sound like Rape Stove.
Or like “Gape-rate”, Mark Zuckerberg’s grotesque pre-Facebook website idea
“What would we call a scandal that took place at the Watergate complex today? Watergate-gate?”
Duh, it’s Watergate II: Political Boogaloo.
Watergate II: The Tricky Dickening
BASF. I don’t make comments… I make comments better.
Maybe we can start doing more like “Iran-Contra”, so this would become Tosh-Rape, or Rape-Tosh.
Anyone who hasn’t commented yet is late-gate. *bowtie spins, rapes other bowtie*
Can this also be the place where we get people to stop adding “-aholic” onto words to show they are addicted to something? There’s no such thing as chocohol, asshole.
So how do I refer to that sorority girl I took home last night? A rohypnaholic?
“I’m a rageaholic! I’m addicted to rageahol!” …Homer
I just took a poop-gate
BRING BACK MATT-GATE!
I move that we drop the suffixes altogether when referring to this story and just give all things Daniel Tosh-related a blanket term: The Unpleasantness.
Sounds a little classier, no?
Your mom sounds a little classier.
Tosh-gate? Really. How unoriginal.
Now Rape-gate is something thats got a real zing to it!
Also: the name for my new S&M Stargate-themed Club. Opening right next to my old club. The Male Room, which is a post office themed gay bar
Lets go ahead and call it Rape-Gate then try in vain to not make a joke about it.
The REAL rape-gate:
again….over 20 years ago George Carlin addressed this and proved rape can be funny ([www.youtube.com])
Porky Pig raping Elmer Fudd? Funny.
Real life woman getting raped by 5 guys? Not so funny.
The real crime is how awful Daniel Tosh’s show is.
It’s gotten better once he ran out of old material he would shoe-horn into random parts of the show.
I have the same problem with people who use “-aholic” at the end of any word to imply that you are addicted to something, like “milk-aholic” or “meat-aholic” (terrible examples, I know – “rape-aholic”, maybe?). The “-ahol” is part of the word “alcohol” and nobody calls you an acoholoholic – unless you really have a problem, I guess. It’s stupid.
…and yes, I realized that I spelled alcohol wrong several times in that post.
If only someone named Col would do something scandalous.
then what are we going to call Watergate-Gate?!?
You mean Rape-Gate isn’t about Sandusky and Penn State? or was that “Rape-Gate-lite”?
Rape State University-Gate
Or The Sandgatesky trial
I don’t think it has been used nearly enough.
The scandal with the politician who sent text messages with pictures of his junk definitely needed to be Boner-Gate.
Also, we haven’t had any scandals yet that begin with the obvious puns.. Surro, Profli, or Casti.
I really can’t see how disliking the universally understood “-gate” suffix is worth a blog. The 9/11-gate was a big deal, as was the Holocaust–gate. This -gate-gate is the hardly on their level and has been written ad nauseum since blog-gate started ending print-media-gate.